Misleader Home A Daily Chronicle of Bush Administration Distortion
Photo: Collage of President Bush and White House
Navigation: Who We Are Navigation: Special Reports Navigation: Ask the Experts Navigation: Feedback Navigation: Donate Navigation: Tell a Friend Navigation: Contact Us

Receive the Daily Mislead
Get a look past the rhetoric, every day, delivered to your inbox.

your email:

Member of the press?


             Privacy policy


In the Spotlight
Bush Campaign Ads . . . Brought to You by Special Interests
As President Bush's $10.5 million campaign ad blitz begins, Public Citizen released a report outlining who helped pay for the campaign ads and what favors they have received during his presidency.


Special Reports
No Child Left Behind? The Funding Gap in ESEA and Other Federal Education Programs
The current reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), known as No Child Left Behind (NCLB), raises high expectations for achievement and imposes stringent measures of accountability on students, teachers, and schools.


See the Ad



A Daily Chronicle of Bush Administration Distortion April 27, 2004
Send The Misleader to a Friend | Printer Friendly Version | Want the Mislead on your site?



     

Bush Misleads Seniors on New Drug Cards



Less than a year ago, President Bush promised Americans that he would "provide seniors with a drug discount card that saves them 10 to 25% off the cost of all drugs, so they'll start seeing savings immediately" on their medications1. But, as the program launches next week, experts have concluded that the cards don't guarantee seniors any savings at all2. Additionally, instead of admitting this, the President used millions in taxpayer money to promote the cards through television ads - ads that government regulators later said were misleading.

As the New York Times reports, the White House plan locks seniors into the cards they initially choose, then allows the card sponsors "to change their prices on a weekly basis," thus never guaranteeing any benefit at all3. Instead of telling the seniors the truth when this reality became apparent, the President used tens of millions of dollars of taxpayer funds to air television ads promising that the drug cards will save seniors money. Some of the ads even used fake reporters in an effort to trick viewers into thinking they were watching objective news4. The General Accounting Office soon concluded that the ads contained "notable omissions and errors"5.

One possible reason the President never forced card sponsors to guarantee savings could be Bush's relationship with a longtime Texas crony and drug card industry executive who could profit from bilking seniors. According to the Boston Globe, the President allowed David Halbert, CEO of drug card company AdvancePCS, to "craft the portion of the Medicare bill" that created the card program, even though Halbert had a financial interest in the bill and has had a close relationship with Bush for years6. For instance, "Bush had been an investor in a Halbert-owned predecessor company to AdvancePCS" and Halbert "contributed to Bush campaigns from his 1994 gubernatorial race through his White House bid in 2000."

Sources:
  1. President Bush Calls for Action on 38th Anniversary of Medicare, 07/30/2003.
  2. "New Drug Card Called Passport To Confusion", Hartford Courant, 04/25/2004.
  3. "Feds will keep drug discount on the up and up", Wichita Eagle, 12/11/2003.
  4. "Publicity Campaign Under Scrutiny", ABC News, 03/15/2004.
  5. "Bush Medicare Reform Bill Become a Nightmare for GOP", Miami Herald, 03/19/2004.
  6. "Bush ally's firm vies for Medicare cards", Boston Globe, 12/12/2003.



Send the Misleader to a Friend | Print It | Misleader Archive