Misleader Home A Daily Chronicle of Bush Administration Distortion
Photo: Collage of President Bush and White House
Navigation: Who We Are Navigation: Special Reports Navigation: Ask the Experts Navigation: Feedback Navigation: Donate Navigation: Tell a Friend Navigation: Contact Us

Receive the Daily Mislead
Get a look past the rhetoric, every day, delivered to your inbox.

your email:

Member of the press?


             Privacy policy


In the Spotlight
Bush Campaign Ads . . . Brought to You by Special Interests
As President Bush's $10.5 million campaign ad blitz begins, Public Citizen released a report outlining who helped pay for the campaign ads and what favors they have received during his presidency.


Special Reports
No Child Left Behind? The Funding Gap in ESEA and Other Federal Education Programs
The current reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), known as No Child Left Behind (NCLB), raises high expectations for achievement and imposes stringent measures of accountability on students, teachers, and schools.


See the Ad



A Daily Chronicle of Bush Administration Distortion February 11, 2004
Send The Misleader to a Friend | Printer Friendly Version | Want the Mislead on your site?



     

Bush Still Refuses To Release Military Documents



White House spokesman Scott McClellanOn Sunday, President Bush pledged in the Oval Office to release any and all documents related to whether he fulfilled his Vietnam-era National Guard duty.1 And yesterday, the White House claimed the documents it released fulfilled that Oval Office pledge. However, just hours after that declaration, White House communications director Dan Bartlett "confirmed that Bush's complete personnel file is being forwarded to Washington from an archive in Denver" but only "for review"2 by the White House - not necessarily release to the public.

Military experts said records like those being "reviewed" by the White House could definitively prove where Bush was, unlike those documents released yesterday, which do not. But records such as those being "reviewed" by the White House "cannot be released without Bush's authorization," a process that would simply require the president to sign release forms.3 To date "Bush has not consented, despite his claim that he made public all his records in 2000."4 Without that authorization, the government has denied Freedom of Information Act5 requests seeking relevant documents.

The White House claimed the documents it released yesterday show "President Bush fulfilling his duties in the National Guard"6during Vietnam. However, the documents released actually showed that Bush "did not receive military pay from May to September of 1972" - a five month gap in service where Bush also "refused to take his annual physical and was grounded as a pilot."7 White House spokesman Scott McClellan refused to say whether Bush actually showed up for service, only saying that Bush was paid. In all, the records "do not show the exact nature or whereabouts of Bush's service during that period."8

In a year spanning 1972 and 1973, Bush claims to have served in the Alabama National Guard and in Houston, but the White House cannot produce a single human being to validate that claim. While Bush says there is "no evidence"9 to prove whether he did or did not show up for service, that is not true - those who would have overseen his service specifically report that he was absent. In Alabama, the commander of the unit Bush would have been in said today, "He never did come to my squad. He was never at my unit."10 Additionally, in a signed report, commanding officers in Houston said Bush "has not been observed."11

Sources:
  1. Meet the Press, 02/08/2004.
  2. "Guard Records On President Are Released", Washington Post, 02/10/2004.
  3. National Personnel Records Center.
  4. "New Bush Guard records raise new questions", Salon, 02/11/2004.
  5. Freedom of Information Act Response to Martin Heldt, 7/19/00.
  6. White House Press Briefing, 2/10/04.
  7. "New Bush Guard records raise new questions," Salon.com, 2/11/04.
  8. "Guard Records On President Are Released", Washington Post, 02/10/2004.
  9. Meet the Press, 02/08/2004.
  10. "Bush met military obligation, aide says," Birmingham News, 2/11/04.
  11. "Guard Records On President Are Released", Washington Post, 02/10/2004.



Send the Misleader to a Friend | Print It | Misleader Archive